Maintenance and the home

Who keeps the family home after separation in Italy

Italian law speaks of the family home and ties it to the children's interests, while ownership and the mortgage follow the rules on spouses' property and on contracts.

In brief

With children, the family home is assigned taking their interests into account first, even if it belongs to only one spouse: whoever obtains it has the right to live there, not ownership. Who owns the home is determined by the rules on spouses' property. As far as the bank is concerned, the mortgage follows the contract, not the assignment.

Who stays in the marital home (casa coniugale) when a couple separates depends first of all on whether there are children. Italian law does not speak of the marital home but of the family home (casa familiare), and provides that the right to use it is assigned taking the children’s interests into account first (Article 337-sexies of the Italian Civil Code). Ownership and the mortgage, by contrast, follow the rules on spouses’ property and on contracts.

The children’s interests

In orders concerning the children, the judge refers exclusively to their moral and material interests. The judge first considers whether the children can remain in the custody of both parents, that is shared custody (affidamento condiviso), and sets how and when they spend time with each parent (Article 337-ter of the Civil Code).

The rules on the family home name neither the mother nor the father. Assignment concerns the use of the home, that is the right to live in it, not its ownership. The judge takes the assignment into account when settling the financial relations between the parents, having regard to any title of ownership.

For divorce there is an additional rule. The right to live in the family home goes preferably to the parent to whom the children are entrusted or with whom they live beyond the age of majority. In any case, when assigning the home the judge assesses the spouses’ financial circumstances and the reasons for the decision, and favours the weaker spouse (Article 6 of Law No. 898 of 1970, the Divorce Act).

As to adult children, those with a serious disability (handicap grave) benefit in full from the provisions laid down for minor children (Article 337-septies of the Civil Code).

Every situation has details a guide can't cover.

Talk to us

Who decides and when

If the spouses agree, they settle the home themselves. The judge takes note of the parents’ agreements, provided they are not contrary to the children’s interests. In a joint application (domanda congiunta), that is a petition to the court signed by both, the spouses set out the terms on the children and on financial matters and can settle their property relations, in whole or in part (Article 473-bis.51 of the Italian Code of Civil Procedure). If the agreements conflict with the children’s interests, the court summons the spouses and indicates the changes to be made.

With assisted negotiation (negoziazione assistita), that is the route by which the spouses, each with their own lawyer, seek an agreement outside court, the agreement reached takes the place of the court orders that settle the separation (Article 6 of Decree-Law No. 132 of 2014). Where there are minor children, adult children who are incapable or have a serious disability, or children who are not financially self-sufficient, the public prosecutor authorises the agreement when it considers that it serves the children’s interests.

Without an agreement, assignment is requested by a petition (ricorso) to the court. Where there are minor children or claims for financial contributions, the petition must also be accompanied by the documents showing rights of ownership or other real rights over immovable property, that is, among other things, who owns the home. How the proceedings unfold is explained in the article on how a judicial separation works.

The judge can decide on the home before the judgment. If conciliation fails at the hearing, the judge issues, in a court order, the temporary and urgent orders (provvedimenti temporanei e urgenti), that is the rules on children, home and maintenance payments that apply until another order replaces them (Article 473-bis.22 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The judge issues them in the interests of the parties, within the limits of their claims, and of the children. These orders can be challenged by a complaint (reclamo), that is by asking the Court of Appeal to review them, within ten days of their pronouncement at the hearing or of their communication, or of service if earlier.

Who owns the home

Who owns the home is determined by the rules on the spouses’ property regime, with or without children. Unless the spouses have chosen a different regime by agreement, the statutory community of property (comunione legale dei beni) applies. It includes purchases made by the spouses during the marriage, jointly or separately, except those relating to personal assets (Article 177 of the Civil Code).

Personal assets, which remain the property of one spouse only, include the home that spouse owned before the marriage and one received afterwards by gift or inheritance, unless the deed of gift or the will assigns it to the community (Article 179 of the Civil Code). Under separation of property (separazione dei beni), chosen by the spouses by agreement, each remains the sole owner of what they buy during the marriage.

The statutory community is dissolved by the personal separation, and the division is made by splitting assets and liabilities in equal shares. If instead the home belongs to both spouses outside the statutory community, for example because they bought it together under separation of property, the rules on co-ownership apply. Each co-owner can always ask for the co-ownership to be dissolved; the judge can set a postponement of no more than five years if immediate dissolution could harm the other’s interests (Article 1111 of the Civil Code).

Without children, the route through the municipality is also open; it is barred where there are minor children, adult children who are incapable or have a serious disability, or children who are not financially self-sufficient. The agreement signed before the civil registrar, however, cannot contain property transfer arrangements; with that agreement, therefore, the home does not pass from one spouse to the other (Article 12 of Decree-Law 132/2014).

Ownership and the mortgage

The assignment order and the revocation order can be registered in the property registers and can be enforced against third parties. For divorce, the law specifies that a registered assignment can be enforced against a third-party purchaser, that is also against someone who buys the home from the owner.

If the home is in the statutory community, on division the judge can, in view of the children’s needs and their custody, grant one spouse a usufruct, that is a right to use and enjoy, over part of the assets due to the other (Article 194 of the Civil Code).

The rules on the family home say nothing about the mortgage, which follows the rules on contracts. A contract has the force of law between the parties and has no effect on third parties, except where the law provides otherwise (Article 1372 of the Civil Code). An agreement between the spouses on who pays the instalments, therefore, does not bind the bank.

If the mortgage contract makes the spouses jointly and severally liable, each can be required to pay the whole debt, and payment by one releases the other (Article 1292 of the Civil Code). Whoever has paid it all can claim from the other only their share. The person living in the home and the person who has to pay the bank can therefore be different people.

When the assignment ends

The right to use the family home ends if the person who obtained it does not live there or stops living there permanently, lives with another person as a couple or remarries (Article 337-sexies of the Civil Code).

Leaving the home before applying for separation raises a different question, which the article on how to separate deals with separately.

How to proceed

Speaking to a lawyer before taking any step is useful above all when there are children and no agreement on who stays in the home, when the home belongs to only one spouse or when there is a mortgage in both names: these are the cases in which the rules on children, on property and on contracts add up. In separation and divorce the firm handles consensual and judicial separation, divorce, assisted negotiation and variation of arrangements. The first consultation is for framing the case: you describe the situation, the firm reads the documents and tells you which routes are open and which are not. At the end of the first consultation you receive a written quote and decide afterwards, with the figures in front of you.

If your situation sounds like this one, let's talk.

Book a first consultation

Frequently asked

We are separating: who stays in the house?

It depends on the children. If there are any, the right to use the family home is assigned taking their interests into account first (Article 337-sexies of the Civil Code), even if the home belongs to only one parent. Who owns the home is determined by the rules on spouses' property, with or without children. Without an agreement, the judge can decide on the home after the first hearing, with the temporary and urgent orders.

The house is in my name: can I lose it if I separate?

Not the ownership: assignment gives the right to live in it. With children, however, the judge can assign it to the other parent (Article 337-sexies of the Civil Code). The home is yours if you owned it before the marriage, if you received it by gift or inheritance and the deed does not assign it to the community, or if you bought it with the proceeds of a personal asset and declared this in the deed. Other homes, bought under the statutory community of property, belong to both of you.

If we have children, does the home always go to the mother?

No. The rules on the family home name neither the mother nor the father: the right to use the home is assigned taking the children's interests into account first. In a divorce, the right to live in the home goes preferably to the parent to whom the children are entrusted or with whom they live beyond the age of majority (Article 6 of Law 898/1970). The judge first considers whether the children can remain in the custody of both parents.

Who pays the mortgage on the home after separation?

As far as the bank is concerned, the mortgage contract decides, not the assignment. Your agreement on who pays the instalments is valid between the two of you, but it does not bind the bank, which is not a party to it. If the mortgage makes you jointly and severally liable, each of you can be required to pay the whole debt (Article 1292 of the Civil Code); whoever has paid it all can claim from the other only their share.

My ex lives with a new partner: can they stay in the house?

If the home had been assigned to them, the right to use the family home ends if they live with another person as a couple, remarry or no longer live permanently in the home (Article 337-sexies of the Civil Code). Revocation is an order that, like the assignment order, can be registered and enforced against third parties.

Avv. Teresa Lo Torto

Attorney since 1994, she founded her independent practice in 1997. In 2008 she earned, summa cum laude, the licentiate in canon law and trained at the Roman Rota. Admitted to the Italian Court of Cassation in 2016, she serves on the boards of non-profit organisations.

By appointment

Let's talk.

Tell us what's happening. We reply within 24 hours on working days and arrange a first consultation, with a clear quote before we begin.

Write to us