Few questions arising from a separation generate as much anxiety as the one about how the children will be cared for. Italian law starts from a clear assumption: a child has the right to maintain a stable, continuous and balanced relationship with both parents, even where those parents no longer live together. The legal architecture built around that principle, codified in Articles 337-bis and following of the Italian Civil Code, gives shared custody (affidamento condiviso) the status of general rule and treats sole custody (affidamento esclusivo) as a reasoned exception. Understanding the difference, and the criteria the courts apply when departing from the rule, helps clarify what is really at stake in a contested case.
The shared-custody principle
Shared custody was introduced into Italian law in 2006, with Law 54/2006, and is now codified in Article 337-ter of the Civil Code. The provision is straightforward: in the event of separation, divorce or end of cohabitation between parents, the judge considers as a matter of priority whether the children can be entrusted to both parents. Parental responsibility, the cluster of duties and powers connected to the upbringing, education, healthcare and overall well-being of the child, is exercised by both parents and, in matters of ordinary administration, the judge may decide that it is exercised separately. Decisions of greater importance, including those on schooling, healthcare other than routine, and habitual residence, must be taken jointly.
A point that often surprises clients, particularly those familiar with common-law systems, is that shared custody under Italian law does not imply equal physical time with the children. The child has a single habitual residence, called collocamento, with one of the parents, and a structured pattern of time with the other. The split between weeks, weekends, holidays and summer breaks is shaped to fit the family’s geography, the children’s school commitments and their developmental needs. The fact that one parent is the placement parent does not weaken the other’s parental responsibility, which remains full and equal.
The judge takes decisions concerning the children with sole reference to their moral and material interests (Article 337-ter of the Civil Code).
When sole custody is ordered
Article 337-quater of the Italian Civil Code allows the judge to depart from the shared-custody rule and to entrust the child to one parent alone where shared custody would be contrary to the child’s best interests. The provision deliberately uses an open-textured criterion, and the case law has progressively given it content. The departure from the rule is not justified by mere conflict between the parents, however intense, nor by the geographical distance between their homes, nor by the simple preference of one parent for a sole-custody arrangement.
What the courts have identified as a sufficient ground for sole custody is a situation in which one parent is objectively unable or unwilling to exercise parental responsibility in a manner consistent with the child’s interest. Typical examples include prolonged disengagement from the child’s life, recurrent behaviour that exposes the child to physical or emotional harm, serious mental-health issues that are not being adequately addressed and substance-abuse problems that interfere with the parental role. The judge orders sole custody by a reasoned decision (Article 337-quater of the Civil Code).
Within the sole-custody framework, the law preserves a residual role for the non-custodial parent. Decisions of major importance for the child must still, in principle, be taken jointly unless the court has expressly excluded that as well; the non-custodial parent retains the right and the duty to oversee the child’s education and upbringing (Article 337-quater of the Civil Code) and the duty to contribute to maintenance. Sole custody, in other words, is a recalibration of responsibility, not a severance of the parental tie.
Hearing the child
Whatever custody arrangement is being considered, the child’s own voice is now a structural element of the proceeding. The child is heard from age twelve and, where capable of discernment, also at a younger age (Article 473-bis.4 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The hearing is conducted by the judge, in conditions suited to the child’s age and maturity, and may be supported by a court-appointed psychological expert and by a curator speciale del minore where there is a conflict of interests between the child and the parents (Articles 473-bis.8 and 78 of the Code of Civil Procedure).
The hearing is not a vote on which parent the child prefers, and Italian judges are alert to signs of suggestion or instrumentalisation. What the hearing aims to bring out is the child’s lived experience of the family situation, the child’s understanding of what is being decided and any clearly expressed wishes that can be assessed in light of the child’s age, maturity and circumstances. The weight given to those wishes increases with the child’s age and degree of autonomy, but they remain one factor among others in a global assessment focused on the child’s best interests.
Modifying a custody arrangement, once it has been decided, is always possible: the relevant rules in Article 337-quinquies of the Italian Civil Code and Article 473-bis.29 of the Italian Code of Civil Procedure allow either parent to apply to the Court for a variation where justified grounds arise. Studio Legale Lo Torto regularly advises Italian and international parents on the design of sustainable custody arrangements and on the review of arrangements that have ceased to fit the family’s reality, drawing on its experience before the family sections of Milan and Venice.
If your situation sounds like this one, let's talk.
Book a first consultationFrequently asked
Is shared custody still the rule?
Yes, it is the general rule; sole custody is a reasoned exception.
When does the judge hear the child?
As a rule from age 12 onwards, but earlier if the child is capable of discernment.
Can I change the custody arrangement?
Yes, by application to the Court, showing a change in the original circumstances.
Does primary residence rule out shared custody?
No, they are distinct concepts: residence concerns where the child habitually lives, custody concerns parental responsibility.
Sources
- Art. 337-ter Civil Code — Provisions regarding the children
- Art. 337-quater Civil Code — Custody by one parent only and opposition to shared custody
- Art. 337-quinquies Civil Code — Review of the provisions concerning the custody of the children
- Art. 78 Code of Civil Procedure — Special curator
- Art. 473-bis.4 Code of Civil Procedure — Hearing of the child
- Art. 473-bis.8 Code of Civil Procedure — Special curator of the child
- Art. 473-bis.29 Code of Civil Procedure — Modification of orders
- Law of 8 February 2006, no. 54 — Provisions on the separation of parents and shared custody of children