The order setting periodic spousal maintenance, whether issued at the separation stage or as part of a divorce judgment, is never a closed chapter. Italian law treats it as a living provision, anchored to the parties’ real circumstances at the time it is decided, and expressly subject to review when those circumstances change. By contrast, divorce maintenance paid in a single lump sum, by agreement of the parties and if the court considers it fair, closes any later claim of an economic nature (Article 5, paragraph 8, of Law 898/1970, the Divorce Act). For both the payer and the recipient, knowing when a revision is possible, and when it is not, is therefore essential. The picture in 2026 reflects an intense evolution of the case law, beginning with the seminal Joint Divisions ruling of 2018 on divorce maintenance.
The principle of variability
The variability of spousal maintenance is codified in Article 156, last paragraph, of the Italian Civil Code for separation and in Article 473-bis.29 of the Code of Civil Procedure for both separation and divorce. Both provisions allow either spouse to apply to the family court for a revision of the maintenance order where there has been a material change in the underlying circumstances. The procedure is governed by the unified family proceedings introduced by Legislative Decree 149/2022 and, in practice, requires both a factual demonstration of the change and a legal demonstration that the change affects the assumptions on which the original order was based.
The 2018 ruling of the Joint Civil Divisions of the Court of Cassation, judgment no. 18287 of 11 July 2018, marked a watershed for divorce maintenance. The Court moved away from the criterion of the marital standard of living alone and recognised that the allowance has an assistance function and an equalising and compensatory function.
Two practical implications follow from the variability of the maintenance order. First, the passage of time alone is not a ground for revision; what counts is whether the parties’ factual situation has shifted. Second, the change must be more than transitory: a temporary downturn in the payer’s income, or a temporary work assignment for the recipient, is unlikely to justify a permanent revision of the order.
Criteria applied by the courts
Within this framework, a number of typical situations recur in the case law of the family courts and of the Court of Cassation. The first, and arguably the most frequent, is the formation of a new stable family unit by the recipient spouse. Divorce maintenance ends if the recipient remarries (Article 5, paragraph 10, of Law 898/1970). For a new stable cohabitation, however, the law lays down no rule: the court decides case by case.
A second cluster of cases concerns the recipient’s economic self-sufficiency. Where the recipient spouse acquires, after the order was issued, a stable income capable of meeting their needs autonomously, or comes into possession of significant assets, the maintenance order is liable to be reduced or revoked, depending on the magnitude of the change. The criterion is not a mathematical comparison of incomes but a substantive assessment of whether the original reason for the order, namely the imbalance the recipient could not be expected to overcome, still exists.
A third recurring situation concerns the payer. Where the payer’s income or assets have undergone a lasting reduction not attributable to fault, for example because of the loss of employment, the failure of a business or supervening incapacity, a reduction of the order is generally available. Italian courts are cautious to ensure that the change is genuine and durable, and applications based on artificial restructuring of the payer’s affairs are routinely rejected.
In every case, the protection of the financially weaker spouse remains in place. Italian family courts have consistently refused to use the modificability of the order as a tool to reverse the assumption that the more vulnerable spouse should not be left without resources, particularly where the contribution made to the family during the marriage explains the post-marital imbalance.
Conclusions and protections
For both payers and recipients, the practical lesson is that the maintenance order is best treated as a structured framework that must be revisited when life moves on. From the payer’s perspective, an application for reduction or revocation requires careful preparation, including documentary evidence of the change relied upon, a clear demonstration that it is not transitory and an explanation of how it affects the assumptions of the original order. A premature or weak application can be counterproductive, both because of the cost it generates and because the court’s reasoning in rejecting it may stiffen the position in any subsequent attempt.
From the recipient’s perspective, the principal protection lies in the quality of the original order. A maintenance order that is well-grounded in evidence, properly framed by reference to the criteria identified by the Court of Cassation and supported by an honest picture of the family’s economic life is far more resilient to subsequent challenges than one drafted in haste. International clients deserve particular attention here, because the cross-border enforcement of an Italian maintenance order under Regulation (EC) No 4/2009 (the Maintenance Regulation) depends, in part, on the clarity of the underlying reasoning.
A revision procedure before the Milan Family Section, or any other competent court, has a length that the law does not fix: it depends on the court’s workload and on the complexity of the case, which grows when income has to be reconstructed or a business valued. Where the application is granted, the order generally takes effect from the date of filing, although the court has discretion to fix a different effective date in light of the circumstances. Studio Legale Lo Torto regularly assists clients in maintenance review proceedings and in the related cross-border enforcement work through its offices in Milan and Venice, and in each case provides a structured early assessment of the prospects of revision before any formal step is taken.
If your situation sounds like this one, let's talk.
Book a first consultationFrequently asked
Can I apply for a reduction of maintenance?
Yes, but you must show the causal link and that the financial change is not merely temporary.
How long does a review procedure take?
The law does not set the overall length. It depends on the workload of the competent court and on the complexity of the case.
Do I need a lawyer?
Yes, both in the appeal stage and in the modification proceedings legal representation is mandatory.
Does Studio Lo Torto only handle cases in Milan?
No, the firm operates from offices in Milan and Venice and acts throughout Italy.
Sources
- Court of Cassation, Joint Divisions, 11 July 2018, no. 18287
- Art. 156 Civil Code — Effects of separation on the financial relations between the spouses
- Law 1 December 1970, no. 898 — Rules on the cases of dissolution of marriage (Article 5)
- Art. 473-bis.29 Code of Civil Procedure — Variability of orders
- Council Regulation (EC) No 4/2009 on maintenance obligations
- C. M. Bianca, Civil Law, 2.1, The Family, 7th ed. edited by M. Bianca and P. Sirena, Giuffrè, 2023